Dependable Erection

Thursday, December 04, 2008

My kind of history

How Helvetica Took Over the Subway

City Room took a day-long tour with Paul Shaw, a New York historian who has an encyclopedic knowledge of signs in the city and in the subway system. He is known to scold people for confusing the terms “typeface,” “lettering,” and “font.” (Font, the word most familiar in an age of software drop-down menus, traditionally had a more narrow definition than “typeface,” but is now conflated with older term.)

Only a typeface aficionado like Mr. Shaw can point out remnants of Helvetica’s predecessor — Standard (also known as Akzidenz Grotesk) — scattered around the underground labyrinth. Mr. Shaw says the subway design team had originally chosen Standard, as the universal typeface in 1966, not Helvetica. A manual of that time declared that, “Of the various weights of sans serif available, Standard Medium has been found to offer the easiest legibility from any angle, whether the passenger is standing, walking or riding” (Sign legibility when your audience is in motion continues to be a vexing problem).

Helvetica was originally created in Switzerland (the name is derived from the Latin word for Swiss). It was a neutral typeface from a neutral country and gained runaway popularity starting in the 1960s for its modern grace. But the subway system looked elsewhere.

“It was an incredibly courageous thing to do at a time when Helvetica was riding high,” Mr. Shaw said.

Seriously, i could spend the whole day following the links from this article to various discussions of how serifs mutated over time, and why subway mosaic tiles look the way they do.

Labels: ,

6 Comments:

  • yeah cool stuff.

    type and film geeks likely know about this already but this film would be of interest (screened at Full Frame year before last) and I think is netflix rentable.

    http://www.helveticafilm.com/

    thank goodness for good signage in NYC subways as viewed from the inside of the car. makes up for the incoherent mumblings of the speaker systems in those trains.

    By Blogger Dave W., at 9:54 AM  

  • the film gets a shout out in the Times article.

    When i lived in Brooklyn, my ride home was the L train from 8th and 14th across town and under the river to the Bedford Ave. stop.

    On good days, we'd have a great conductor with a heavy New England accent intoning "This is the Brooklyn bound L train departing 8th Avenue. Next stop, sixth Avenue. Step lively, and stand clear o' the closing doors."

    I was very disappointed on my recent trip to New York when all of the subway announcements i heard were obviously pre-recorded.

    "Step lively, and stand clear o' the closing doors" remained a tag line for me for years after i moved out of the city.

    By Blogger Barry, at 10:09 AM  

  • This post made me think of this.

    By Blogger Brian, at 11:33 AM  

  • I didn't know you loved or even liked fonts.

    I am a huge font geek. We'll have to talk about it, but in a way that doesn't tire the heck out of everyone else, tonight at drinking liberally.

    I have a copy of the Helvetica movie that Dave mentioned, on DVD, if you'd like to borrow it.

    It's really great, & really blows your mind to see the living breathing folks who designed some of the basic fonts we use on an everyday basis.

    By Blogger john owens-ream, at 2:54 PM  

  • mad props to Bedford Ave., I had no idea you were the willburg type.

    I used to live at 84 N 9th St., with a killer view of the NY skyline and my office across the river in the Met Life Bldg. This was back before the hipsters invaded, when there was no heat in my converted loft and you didn't see Vice Magazine everywhere.

    Great article. I recommend joining the infrequent listserv for the MTA auctions, which offers up all kinds of typefaced goodies. I scored the original enameled sign "6 uptown -- Park Av. & 33rd St." that graced my commute every day.

    The Helvetica film got a lot of play this past summer when I was living in Switzerland, and that's saying something given how the font is everywhere in Zurich. It would be like us making a present-day movie on the Durham Bulls.

    By Blogger KeepDurhamDifferent!, at 6:56 PM  

  • see this post and this post for some Brooklyn stuff.

    i lived at 179 N. 8th St. for 1.5 years between 84 and 86, long enough to see Joan Benoit and Grete Waits run the NYC marathon one year (probably November 84?), but not long enough to see the Brooklyn Brewery open up.

    By Blogger Barry, at 10:03 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home